Celebrity Fashion Smackdown. Who Wore It Better? Second City Style Fashion Blog

Who needs the awards red carpet? There are plenty of events for celebs to attend. Lucky for us...

Rachel Bilson vs Tory Burch in Chanel

Winner: Rachel Bilson. I applaud both for pulling their hair back to expose the amazing neckline of the dress and showing off their shoulders, but the color is better with Rachel's skin tone. I also prefer her black shoes to Tory's (wait, not Reva's?). Why isn't Tory Burch wearing her own line anyway (yes, it was a Chanel event)?

Amanda Bynes vs Paris Hilton in Alice + Olivia

Winner: Amanda Bynes. I don't understand why Paris feels the need to pair every dress she wears with dark opaque tights. I mean she lives in L.A. If I lived there I would never wear the damn things again! Nothing beats a bare leg (as long as they are good). I also love Amanda's Loubies! We just hope she didn't get this dress illegally.

Eva Mendes vs Bonnie Somerville in Dolce & Gabbana

Winner: Eva Mendes. OK, Eva Mendes wins almost all the time because she looks fab in pretty much everything. If I were a red carpet celeb I would check to see that every dress I was about to wear was never seen previously on Eva Mendes. Seriously. This dress is no exception. It's a tough color to pull off and while it looks great on Bonnie too, Eva's skin tone is a better compliment. It pops on her whereas it blends with Bonnie's skin and hair.

Christy Turlington vs Diane Kruger in Chanel

Winner: Christy Turlington. Diane lost me with the shoes. I am not one to say shoes should match the bag. In fact, I'm over it. However, their should be some correlation and there is none. Also Diane looks a little ghostly in the dress, but I do like her hair style.

Sienna Miller vs Lucy Liu Alexander McQueen

Winner: I am going with Lucy Liu. One, the color totally pops on her. Two, I love the belt with the dress which plays up the amazing drapping detail. Three, the length is better above the knee on Lucy and mid-calf on Sienna which is never a good place to be. The dress looks like a sac on Sienna. She either needed another size or a tailor.

-Lauren Dimet Waters
Photos: People.com